Tuesday, September 28, 2010

the medical dilemmas

We went for a meeting with Liam's teacher yesterday to discuss what he needs to be doing to make sure that he's working up to the best of his ability. Homework for Liam takes hours to complete. It is not an easy sitting down and getting it done. I remember fifth grade homework for Diane usually taking about 15 minutes. With Liam, the same amount takes several hours.
One of the suggestions that his teacher gave us is to get him CBT or Cognitive Behavioral Therapy.  From the website of the National Association of Cognitive Behavior Therapy:

      Cognitive-behavioral therapy is based on the idea that our thoughts
    cause our feelings and behaviors, not external things, like people, situations,
    and events.  The benefit of this fact is that we can change the way we think to
    feel / act better even if the situation does not change.


There is also a therapy for Tourette Syndrome called CBiT or Comprehensive Behavioral Intervention for Tics that is supposed to be very effective in reducing tics in some TS patients. From the TSA USA website:

Comprehensive Behavioral Intervention for Tics (CBIT) is a new evidence-based non-pharmacological treatment option for tic management developed by members of the Tourette Syndrome Association (TSA) Behavioral Sciences Consortium.
CBIT procedures combine elements of habit reversal training with psycho education and function-based behavioral interventions to teach patients effective tic management skills.

Great! So there's all these treatment options to help my child with dealing with his tics with a cognitive behavioral approach, right? Not so much. When we first went to see Dr. Brown (our neurologist) and brought up CBiT with him, he said that he didn't think that there was anyone working with it nearby who he could recommend. It was very labor intensive and unless done very well, not very effective. And that many people who had had success with it went on to larger cities to work with larger populations and more prestigious programs. I placed a call to the Yale Child Study Center at Yale New Haven Hospital in Connecticut where they do CBiT. I asked the woman who answered if they accept my insurance. I was told that they do not take insurance, the fees are all paid out of pocket and then you can submit to your insurance company to see if they will pay the insured back for any of the out of pocket expense. The program there appears to be once a week for 6 (sometimes shorter) to 8 months.
I also placed a call to the OCD Study at Bradley Hospital in Rhode Island. I know that they do CBT therapy and was told by a friend whose son was exhibiting tics related to his OCD that the treatment that he received there helped his tics completely diminish. I explained to the woman that Liam's primary diagnosis was TS comorbid with ADHD and to a lower level OCD and Anxiety and asked if they do CBT therapy with TS kids. She said that she was not aware of this, but would speak to a therapist and get back to me.
I then went to my very best source, the wonderful President of our local TS chapter who is looking into it for me with the Dr. that we work with at the local TSA chapter and also through his notes from the national TSA conference.

I find it sad that it's so easy to just keep prescribing these kids different meds when there are non-pharmaceutical therapies out there that are proven to work, yet it's so hard to get them. The recent Discovery Health Network documentary on TS alluded to this as well showing a surgery that greatly diminished one child's tics with great out of pocket expense to the family.
Looking forward to a hopeful answer from our local TSA.

5 comments:

  1. Beth - check out the OCD foundation website and see if they have a list of contacts for therapists that specialize in CBT. They are hard to find, but there are some good ones out there. We drive 2 hours one way to see our psychologist and it has been well worth it. We went through CBT for my son's OCD, as well as recently, we went through CBT for coping and resiliency in dealing with TS for the long haul. Both times, we were able to participate in a medical study so we received the therapy free! Yes, we drive 2 hours one way but it has been SO worth it. Don't give up looking....there are some great therapies that work so much better than all the side effects of meds. The therapy isn't necessarily easy....but remember they are developing life skills that will help them cope for the rest of their life. Since the mental health parity act some insurances are covering it a little better. Hope that helps!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks so much! My friend whose son received help from the OCD clinic at Bradley said that they were accepted as part of a study as well. At this point I'm going to wait to hear from the local TSA as I think they'll have the best idea of where to start, but am holding out hope that this can be a help.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi!
    Speaking from the end that does research (not in this area specifically, but in additional areas where potentially beneficial results get weeded out through lack of staff, funding, and policy), it is incredibly frustrating to have found an intervention that works...and then have it take years to get into place. AND when it is in place, have it look so distorted due to regulations that it's questionable to what degree it WILL help...it's frustrating.
    It's stories like this that make my heart ache because there are such great things being done, but they are not reaching all of those who need it yet. I understand the need for careful consideration before large scale implementation, but still, when there's a need...it should be considered. And carefully considered, not just tossed pills at!

    Thanks for sharing this!
    Sometimes there are collaborative projects between PA and RI/MA. If I hear anything, I'll let you know!

    Meghan "misses playing piano with Liam" Bathgate

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you so much for keeping us in mind Miss Meghan!!!
    We miss you so much, too.
    But in the something good came from it column, Liam is REALLY loving trombone, and I don't think he would have taken a break from piano to try something new if you were here. Hope all is well in PA.

    ReplyDelete